He signed this with a paint pen.
Indianapolis Colt Football Cards - The Best Current Cards for Sale
Pat McAfee Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey JSA Coa Autographed WWE
Pat McAfee Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (Beckett COA)
INDIANAPOLIS COLTS WVU PAT MCAFEE signed INSCRIBED AUTHENTIC FULLSIZE HELMET JSA
Indianapolis Colts Collecting Guide, Tickets, Jerseys
Pat McAfee Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey PSA DNA Coa Autographed WWE
Pat McAfee SIGNED Indianapolis Colts Jersey Stitched XL JSA Authentication COA
Autographed Indianapolis Colts Full-Size Helmets, Autographed Colts Full-Size Helmets, Colts Autographed Memorabilia
Football- Sports Card and Sports Memorabilia Auctions
Indianapolis Colts Collecting Guide, Tickets, Jerseys
Autographed Indianapolis Colts Full-Size Helmets, Autographed Colts Full-Size Helmets, Colts Autographed Memorabilia